long lasting, true black, and cheap!! but does NOOOTT handle water. I have very watery eyes so It does run a little

this was my very first liquid eyeliner - it’s so easy to use because of the shape of the pen and the shape of the tip. it’s pigmented and long lasting and is just so good, especially for the price.

I love many Elf products, but this went completely dry after only a week ot using…disappointing as it’s my second time trying a liquid eyeliner, the first one was a different one, that was dried out upon opening.

This eyeliner is probably one of the best I've ever used.

The brush is nice and fine, making it easy to do sharper tips, and it's also pretty pigmented.

Not too sure about how long it will wear for yet as I didn't use this eyeliner with the intention of wearing it out that day, but it seems like it will wear for quite a while as it didn't smudge when I was doing the rest of my makeup, and took some effort to get off.

It's ok, not really pigmentation